Court Finds Six Councillors Broke the Law in an Attempt to Appoint Elaine Moore to Replace MPP Charmaine Williams

Mayor of Brampton Patrick Brown

BRAMPTON, ON – Earlier today, The Ontario Superior Court of Justice found the motion six Councillors pre-emptively  passed to appoint Elaine Moore for the vacancy created by Charmaine Williams winning in the provincial election illegal.  The six Councillors responsible for being in contravention of the Municipal Act were Gurpreet Dhillon, Charmaine  Williams, Martin Medeiros, Pat Fortini, Doug Whillans and Jeff Bowman. Justice Doi states in their decision that the court is  “…satisfied that the Resolution and By-law were passed without lawful jurisdiction and should be quashed in their entirety  for illegality.” 

From day one, six Councillors behind closed doors to maintain a disruptive stranglehold on Council, at the expense of  residents, orchestrated this illegal motion. These Councillors made backroom deals and chose Elaine Moore, who had zero  connections to wards 7 & 8 and is best known for her opposition to the LRT as a past councillor and supporting a religious  discriminatory policy as a former school trustee, to replace Charmaine Williams.  

Members of the public were also denied an opportunity to apply for the vacant position or to provide input on the selection  process contrary to the democratic precedent followed by every other municipality, including most recently seen in Toronto  for the now vacant Ward 1 formerly held by Michael Ford. 

During the Special Council meeting on May 31, Councillor Harkirat Singh tried to put motions forward to seek legal advice  in a closed session and get a third-party legal opinion on the legality of the motion. Each time the same six Councillors  denied him. He had repeatedly warned his colleagues that the motion to appoint was contrary to the Municipal Act during the  meeting, which the City Clerk and City Solicitor also confirmed. The same six Councillors promptly fired the City Solicitor  thereafter in a baffling and disturbing move. 

Fearing repercussions of the illegal motion on future decisions of Council and believing it was his responsibility as a  Councillor to protect the City and taxpayers, Councillor Singh took it upon himself to initiate legal proceedings to stop the  appointment so the City could be protected from future legal challenges, potentially saving taxpayers millions of dollars.  

We hope this has taught a valuable lesson to the six Councillors that thought they were above the Municipal Act and could  ignore it contrary to ample warnings and expert advice. We remain shocked that six Councillors, five of whom are serving in  their second term and one who has served only one term and is now an MPP responsible for Provincial legislation, had such a  poor understanding of the Municipal Act and their own fiduciary responsibility to the city of Brampton and its residents. We  are also disturbed by the manner in which these Councillors took to the media in order to embarrass the city and Council with what we now know was an illegal position.  

As a result, Councillors Palleschi and Santos will be moving a motion to have Councillors, this term and future terms, attend mandatory training on the Municipal Act and their fiduciary responsibilities to protect taxpayers. Additionally, we hope that  as this term of Council ends in the next few months, Councillors will prioritize protecting the taxpayer rather than focusing  on petty personal vendettas.

SOURCE Office of Mayor Patrick Brown

Be the first to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.